Site icon Policy Circle

UK economy in crisis: Policymakers struggle amid conflicting signals

UK economy in trouble

With high inflation, foreign asset dominance, and looming fiscal constraints, the UK economy must pivot towards industrial revival, trade reform, and smarter taxation.

The UK economy stands at a crossroads, grappling with a mix of tentative resilience and deep-seated structural vulnerabilities. While recent data points to pockets of strength—buoyant retail sales and improved consumer sentiment—underlying weaknesses persist. Stagnant productivity, persistent inflationary pressures, and an economy heavily exposed to foreign capital flows pose formidable challenges. For the Labour government, which entered office on a platform of economic renewal, the task ahead is stark: restoring stability and fostering sustainable growth in a global landscape fraught with uncertainty.

The UK economy posted a modest 0.1% GDP growth in the final quarter of 2024. While the GDP expanded by 0.9% for the whole year, the economy remains fragile, with inflationary pressures and looming tax hikes threatening business confidence and household finances.

READCryptocurrency as a strategic financial tool

Stagnation and inflation

A flurry of contradictory economic signals has left policymakers at the Bank of England (BoE) and the Treasury grappling with a stagflationary dilemma—slow growth coupled with persistent inflationary pressures. A key concern is the labour market, where businesses are cutting jobs at a rate comparable to previous economic crises, yet job postings increased in January for the first time in seven months. This suggests uncertainty rather than outright contraction in employment trends.

United Kingdom GDP growth rate (%)

UK economy inflation rate (%)

Inflation remains stubbornly above target, with forecasts suggesting it could peak at 3.7%—or even 4%—by late 2025. This complicates the BoE’s approach to monetary policy, limiting the scope for aggressive interest rate cuts. Governor Andrew Bailey and other policymakers have emphasised the need to maintain a restrictive stance on interest rates to combat underlying inflation, largely fuelled by wage pressures and global supply disruptions. This means UK households and businesses will continue to face high borrowing costs, further dampening economic activity.

Constraints on government policy

Chancellor Rachel Reeves is confronted with a narrowing fiscal space, compounded by weaker-than-expected tax revenues in January and mounting economic pressures. While Labour has committed to fiscal responsibility through its “ironclad” rules, meeting these commitments may necessitate spending cuts or additional tax hikes—neither of which are politically or economically palatable in the current climate.

One immediate challenge is the planned rise in National Insurance contributions and a 7% hike in the minimum wage set to take effect in April. While designed to improve public finances and boost incomes, respectively, these measures are expected to raise business costs, potentially leading to higher prices and job losses. The business community has already expressed concerns over these policies, warning of the impact on hiring and wage-setting decisions.

The global trade environment further constrains the UK’s fiscal outlook. The latest US tariffs under President Donald Trump’s administration have introduced new uncertainties for British exporters, particularly in industries such as steel and aluminium. The UK government has been forced to engage in last-minute trade negotiations to avoid being caught in the crossfire of a looming trade war that could further disrupt economic growth.

Foreign ownership and economic dependency

A deeper issue confronting the UK economy is its growing dependence on foreign ownership. Decades of privatisation and financial liberalisation have left critical sectors—ranging from energy and transport to technology and retail—in the hands of foreign multinational corporations. Nearly 38% of all turnover in UK non-financial businesses is now generated through foreign-owned companies, raising concerns over economic sovereignty, profit repatriation, and long-term investment in domestic industries.

This model of economic liberalisation, once hailed as a strategy for attracting foreign direct investment, has instead contributed to declining state capacity, higher inequality, and an economy vulnerable to external shocks. The rapid sell-off of public assets has meant that critical infrastructure—including railways, water utilities, and energy networks—are often controlled by foreign investors with profit maximisation, rather than public welfare, as their primary objective.

Potential pathways to economic stability

Despite these challenges, the UK economy is not without avenues for revival. A combination of targeted policy interventions, industrial strategy, and a recalibrated approach to trade and investment can help steer the economy toward sustainable growth.

Addressing inflation while supporting growth: The BoE must strike a balance between inflation control and economic growth. A cautious approach to interest rate reductions, while ensuring monetary policy remains accommodative enough to support investment, is crucial. Encouraging productivity gains through technology adoption and skills development can help offset wage-driven inflation without triggering mass job losses.

Strengthening domestic industries: The government should prioritise strategic investment in high-value sectors such as green energy, advanced manufacturing, and technology. The establishment of a National Wealth Fund to finance domestic industrial projects can help counterbalance foreign dominance in key sectors. Renationalisation efforts in the railway sector should be expanded to other critical industries to ensure long-term public interest alignment.

Reforming trade policy: The UK must actively negotiate trade agreements that protect its domestic industries while expanding export opportunities beyond traditional markets. Reducing reliance on the US and the EU through diversification into emerging markets can provide a buffer against geopolitical and economic shocks. A review of current trade policies to mitigate the risks posed by Trump-era tariffs is essential. Engaging in multilateral trade forums such as the G7 and G20 to push back against protectionist trends is another necessary step.

Fiscal sustainability without austerity

Raising capital gains taxes and implementing wealth taxes could help bridge the fiscal gap without disproportionately burdening the working and middle classes. A more progressive approach to corporate taxation, particularly targeting tax-avoiding multinational corporations, can ensure that foreign-owned entities contribute their fair share to the UK economy.

Public investment in infrastructure, healthcare, and education should be prioritised to enhance long-term growth potential rather than resorting to further austerity measures.

The UK economy is at a crossroads. The interplay of high inflation, sluggish growth, and external trade uncertainties presents a crisis for policymakers. However, by adopting a more strategic and interventionist approach—one that prioritises domestic resilience over financial liberalisation—the government can lay the groundwork for a more sustainable and equitable economic future.

Addressing long-term structural weaknesses, ensuring fairer wealth distribution, and reducing dependency on foreign capital will be key to breaking free from the cycle of stagnation and inequality. The UK must learn from past policy missteps and embrace a new economic paradigm—one that places the interests of its citizens and industries at the heart of decision-making.

Exit mobile version