US vs China: Few questions have captured the world’s imagination in the 21st century as much as whether China will eventually surpass the United States as the largest economy. This debate is not just a numbers game — it reflects a profound geopolitical shift that could redefine global power dynamics. The rivalry between the world’s two largest economies has implications far beyond global trade, influencing everything from technological innovation and military strength to the architecture of international institutions. As China’s rapid rise challenges the long-standing dominance of the US, the stakes are immense, and the answer to this question will shape the course of international relations in the decades to come.
The ongoing rivalry between the United States and China is a battle for global economic supremacy. Reports from global financial institutions and think tanks paint a complex picture of the two nations’ economic trajectories. Can China, currently the world’s second-largest economy, surpass the United States in the coming decades? The answer hinges on several factors, including growth rates, structural challenges, trade policies, and the evolving global economic order.
READ | Online pharmacies: Balancing convenience and controversy
US vs China: A tale of two economies
The United States and China represent two fundamentally different economic models. The US operates a consumption-driven, innovation-heavy, and service-oriented economy, while China relies heavily on exports and manufacturing, bolstered by significant state intervention.
The US economy has demonstrated remarkable resilience in recent years, driven by robust consumer spending and a strong labour market. In 2024, the US achieved a real GDP growth rate of 2.5%, higher than expected, even as inflationary pressures persisted. However, challenges loom. Growth in the first quarter of 2025 slowed to 1.6%, and consumer spending is predicted to taper off. The unemployment rate, which has remained low, is expected to inch up to 4%. Despite these challenges, the US continues to benefit from its innovation ecosystem and financial dominance. The dollar remains the global reserve currency, giving the US significant leverage in global trade and finance.
China, on the other hand, posted an annualised growth rate of 5.3% in the first quarter of 2024, slightly exceeding expectations. However, the picture is far from rosy. The Chinese economy faces a range of structural issues, including a property-sector crisis, declining foreign investment, and weakening consumer confidence. Reports indicate that China’s economic growth is slowing, with the IMF predicting a 4.6% expansion in 2024—well below its pre-pandemic averages. China’s economic strategy hinges on transitioning from an export-driven model to one powered by domestic consumption. However, this shift has proven challenging. Moreover, China’s reliance on state-owned enterprises and heavy-handed economic controls has led to inefficiencies, making its economic trajectory increasingly uncertain.
The trade battlefield
Trade remains a flashpoint in US vs China tussle. In 2024, trade between the two nations totalled over $530 billion, but the US trade deficit with China exceeded $270 billion. This imbalance has long been a source of tension, prompting successive US administrations to impose tariffs and other restrictions.
Donald Trump’s return to the White House has reignited fears of an escalating trade war. His proposal for a 10% tariff on all Chinese imports, with the potential to increase to 60%, signals a renewed effort to curb China’s economic influence. Chinahas warned of the global consequences of a trade war, sayingthere will be no winners in such conflicts. Trade wars disproportionately affect China, which remains heavily reliant on exports for growth. However, retaliatory tariffs on US goods, particularly agricultural products, have also hurt American farmers and industries. Both nations acknowledge that decoupling their economies is not a viable option, but achieving a fair trade relationship remains elusive.
The GDP gap: Nominal vs PPP
One of the most contentious aspects of the US vs China economic rivalry is the comparison of GDP. Using nominal GDP (measured at market exchange rates), the US economy remains significantly larger than China’s, with a gap that has widened to $10 trillion since 2020. However, when measured in purchasing power parity (PPP)—which adjusts for cost-of-living differences—China’s GDP has already surpassed the US.
The divergence between these metrics has led to conflicting narratives. Nominal GDP is a more accurate measure of global economic influence, as it reflects a country’s ability to trade and invest internationally. On the other hand, PPP better captures domestic economic output and living standards. China’s nominal GDP has been constrained by the yuan’s depreciation against the dollar. However, this depreciation has also enhanced China’s export competitiveness, underscoring the dual-edged nature of exchange rates. If China were to allow its currency to appreciate, its nominal GDP could surge, potentially altering the global perception of its economic power.
Structural challenges and long-term projections
Both the US and China face significant structural challenges that could shape their economic futures. China’s economic headwinds include demographic challenges, such as an aging population and declining birth rates, which pose long-term risks to its workforce and productivity. Additionally, high levels of corporate and local government debt, coupled with a struggling property sector, threaten financial stability. Despite advancements in sectors like electric vehicles and renewable energy, China still lags behind the US in some cutting-edge technologies such as semiconductors. Furthermore, increasing scrutiny from Western nations and trade restrictions could limit China’s access to critical technologies and markets.
Despite these challenges, China holds significant advantages over the US economy in certain areas. It remains the world’s largest manufacturing hub, producing goods at a scale unmatched by any other nation. Its dominance in industries like electric vehicles, renewable energy, and infrastructure provides a strong foundation for future growth.
Additionally, China’s massive domestic market, supported by a population of over 1.4 billion, gives it an unparalleled consumer base for long-term economic potential. China’s centralised decision-making allows for swift implementation of large-scale policies, which can be a critical advantage in addressing economic bottlenecks or capitalising on emerging opportunities.
The US, meanwhile, is not without its own challenges. Domestic political instability and frequent policy shifts undermine long-term economic planning. Rising government debt and deficits could constrain public investment in infrastructure and social programs. Moreover, the US relies heavily on Chinese manufacturing for electronics and machinery, making it vulnerable to supply chain disruptions. These structural issues, if left unaddressed, could impact the US’s economic resilience.
Economic dominance is not determined solely by GDP figures. Military spending, technological innovation, and geopolitical alliances are equally important. While China leads in manufacturing and infrastructure, the US retains an edge in innovation, financial power, and global influence. Given current trends, the window for China to overtake the US as the largest economy is narrowing. Experts like George Magnus argue that the great crossover may never occur, as China’s growth slows and its structural weaknesses become more pronounced. However, under PPP metrics, China is already ahead, emphasising its domestic production strength.
The US-China economic rivalry is far from over, but the dynamics are shifting. While the US maintains a robust economy bolstered by innovation and financial strength, China’s growth model faces mounting challenges. Whether China can overtake the US as the largest economy depends not only on its ability to address structural issues but also on how both nations address their complex trade and geopolitical relationship. For now, the US remains the dominant global economic power. But the world will be watching closely as the two giants continue their race for supremacy.