After nearly a decade of stalled negotiations, India and the European Union have restarted talks on a comprehensive free trade agreement. The renewed discussions, which began in 2022, aim to deepen economic ties between two of the world’s largest economies. With the global economic landscape undergoing significant shifts due to geopolitical tensions, supply chain disruptions, and the push for diversification, the India-EU FTA holds immense potential to reshape trade and investment flows. However, the path to a final agreement is fraught with challenges that require careful navigation.
The restart of FTA talks comes at a critical juncture for both India and the EU. The COVID-19 pandemic and the Russia-Ukraine conflict have exposed vulnerabilities in global supply chains, prompting nations to seek reliable and diversified trade partners. For the EU, India represents a strategic alternative to reduce dependence on China. Conversely, India sees the EU as a key market for its goods and services and a source of advanced technology and investment.
READ | Trump’s Neanderthal realism faces its breaking point
Significance of India-EU FTA
The EU is India’s third-largest trading partner, accounting for €88 billion in trade in 2022, while India is the EU’s 10th-largest partner (European Commission, 2023). However, this figure represents only a fraction of the potential, given the size and complementarity of the two economies. An FTA could boost bilateral trade by up to 65 percent, according to a study by the European Parliament (2022).
The recent visit of the European Commission’s Executive Vice-President to India underscores the growing momentum in bilateral relations. The visit focused on advancing trade negotiations, strengthening cooperation in technology and supply chain resilience, and addressing challenges such as sustainability and digital trade.
India’s broader trade strategy also plays a crucial role in its renewed push for an FTA with the EU. The country has been actively pursuing free or preferential trade agreements to enhance market access and reduce tariff barriers. India is currently engaged in FTA negotiations with the United Kingdom, the EU, and Oman, while also exploring a bilateral trade agreement with the United States. The US’s impending reciprocal tariff measures, set to take effect on April 2, could impact Indian exports in key sectors such as chemicals, automobiles, textiles, and footwear. This evolving global trade scenario highlights the urgency for India to secure favorabletrade deals, including the India-EU FTA, to safeguard its economic interests and expand its global footprint.
Key areas of negotiation
Market access for goods: Tariff reduction is a central pillar of the FTA talks. The EU seeks greater access to India’s market for automobiles, wines, spirits, and dairy products, while India aims to lower tariffs on its textiles, pharmaceuticals, and agricultural exports. However, sensitive sectors like agriculture and automobiles remain contentious. For instance, India’s high tariffs on European wines and spirits have long been a point of debate (Ministry of Commerce and Industry, 2023).
Services and digital trade: India’s IT and services sector, which contributes over 50 percent to its GDP, is a key area of interest. The EU’s demand for greater access to India’s services market, coupled with India’s push for easier mobility for its skilled professionals, will be a critical part of the negotiations. Additionally, digital trade and data localization rules are expected to feature prominently, given the growing importance of the digital economy.
Sustainability and labour standards: The EU has emphasized the inclusion of sustainability clauses, including commitments to the Paris Agreement and labor rights. While India has made significant strides in renewable energy and sustainability, aligning with the EU’s stringent standards could pose challenges for certain industries.
Intellectual property rights: The EU’s push for stronger IPR protections, particularly in pharmaceuticals, could clash with India’s generic drug industry, which is a global leader in affordable medicines. Balancing innovation with access to essential medicines will be a delicate task.
Investment protection agreement: Parallel to the FTA, negotiations on an Investment Protection Agreement (IPA) are also underway. India is keen to ensure that the IPA aligns with its revised investment treaty framework, emphasizing sovereign policy space while addressing investor concerns over dispute resolution mechanisms.
Challenges and roadblocks
Despite the optimism surrounding the talks, several challenges remain:
Protectionism and sensitive sectors: Both sides have historically protected certain sectors. For example, India’s dairy industry, which supports millions of small farmers, is likely to resist competition from European imports.
Regulatory divergence: Differences in standards and regulations, particularly in agriculture and pharmaceuticals, could slow progress.
Geopolitical considerations: The EU’s close ties with Pakistan and its stance on issues like Kashmir could complicate negotiations, though both sides have expressed a commitment to keeping trade and politics separate.
Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM): The EU’s new carbon tariff on imports may affect India’s carbon-intensive industries, particularly steel and aluminum exports.
Opportunities for India
Increased access to the EU’s 450 million consumers could boost India’s exports and create jobs. The EU is a major source of foreign direct investment (FDI) and advanced technologies, particularly in renewable energy and manufacturing.
Reducing dependence on China and strengthening ties with the EU aligns with India’s broader economic and geopolitical strategy. An FTA could also open doors for partnerships in renewable energy, electric vehicles, and sustainable infrastructure development.
The India-EU FTA talks are expected to be complex and time-consuming. A pragmatic approach that balances ambition with flexibility will be essential. Confidence-building measures, such as early harvest agreements on less contentious issues, could help build momentum.
A strong India-EU partnership is not just an economic imperative but a strategic necessity in today’s world. The success of these talks could set a new benchmark for global trade agreements in an increasingly fragmented world.